Introduction: The Harsh Reality Every Team Leader Faces
In real estate, there’s one brutal truth every team leader has to face: your top producer will leave.
It’s not a question of if — it’s when.
Maybe it’s for a bigger split, maybe it’s because another team offered better support, maybe it’s because they simply want to try running their own thing. But sooner or later, the person who carries most of your production will walk out the door.
When that happens, your team either:
- Crumbles because everything depended on one star agent.
- Or doesn’t miss a beat because you already have a recruiting system running in the background.
This guide will walk you through the exact recruiting strategies top-performing teams are using in 2025 to avoid disaster and build a sustainable pipeline of talent.
Why Top Producers Leave (It’s Not What You Think)
Team leaders often think agents leave for more money. In reality, money is rarely the only reason.
Here’s the breakdown:
| Reason Agents Leave | Leader’s Assumption | Reality Check |
| Higher splits elsewhere | “They’re greedy” | Agents leave for growth, support, and culture — splits are just the surface. |
| Better recruiting pitch | “That recruiter stole them” | Poaching only works when your value proposition is weak. |
| Lack of loyalty | “They were ungrateful” | Loyalty follows leadership, mentorship, and growth opportunities. |
Stat (NAR 2024 Report): 36% of agents who switched brokerages cited lack of leadership support as their main reason for leaving.
Bottom line: stop thinking about “locking in” agents. Instead, build a system that keeps attracting talent consistently.
The Economics of Recruiting: Why It’s Not Optional
Losing one top producer isn’t just a headache — it’s expensive.
- Lost commission revenue.
- Lost referrals and repeat clients tied to that agent.
- Cost of onboarding and training replacements.
- Culture dip when other agents see turnover.
Compare that to the cost of running a consistent recruiting system: advertising spend, recruiter salary (or commissions), CRM tools. Recruiting is cheaper than turnover — every single time.
👉 Formula:
If one top producer generates $500K in GCI and leaves, you’re not just losing $500K. You’re losing the referrals, the team energy, and often another 1–2 agents who follow them out the door.
The 2025 Recruiting Playbook for Real Estate Teams
1. Build a Recruiting Funnel, Not a Job Post
Agents don’t wake up and Google “real estate jobs near me.”
The best ones aren’t actively looking — they’re open to better opportunities if you show up with the right message.
A recruiting funnel should look like this:
| Stage | Tools | Goal |
| Awareness | Paid ads, social media, SEO blogs | Get in front of potential recruits |
| Interest | Landing pages, videos, webinars | Position your team as the solution |
| Decision | 1:1 calls, culture events, recruiting interviews | Convert to joiners |
| Retention | Mentorship, tech, support | Keep them longer |
SEO tip: Optimize landing pages with phrases like real estate agent jobs [city], join real estate team 2025, real estate recruiting opportunities.
2. Craft Job Ads That Actually Work
Most team leaders throw up a generic ad that says “Join Our Team!” and wonder why nobody applies.
Your ad headline is 80% of the battle. It has to speak directly to pain points and desires.
| Generic (Weak) | Magnetic (Strong) |
| “Real Estate Agents Wanted” | “Tired of Chasing Leads? Join a Team That Hands Them to You” |
| “Hiring Now: Real Estate Team” | “Ready to Double Your Closings Without Doubling Your Hours?” |
| “Competitive Splits Offered” | “Sell More Homes With Our Leads, Systems & Support” |
Checklist: What Every Recruiting Ad Needs
- Attention-grabbing headline.
- Clear pain-point solution (leads, training, support).
- Social proof (team stats, agent testimonials).
- Call to action (“Apply now for confidential interview”)
3. Social Media Recruiting: The Daily Non-Negotiable
Social media is where your recruits are watching.
What to post daily in 2025:
- Behind-the-scenes team training clips.
- Agent success stories.
- Quick recruiting tips.
- Culture content (retreats, team events).
- Market insights positioning you as a leader.
Best platforms right now:
- Instagram Reels
- LinkedIn (great for targeting experienced agents)
- TikTok (younger agents & brand awareness)
📊 2025 Trend: Short-form video posts drive 4X more recruiting inquiries than static ads.
4. Technology That Powers Recruiting
You wouldn’t run a sales pipeline on sticky notes. Don’t run recruiting that way either.
The 2025 Recruiting Tech Stack
| Tool | Use |
| CRM (Follow Up Boss, GoHighLevel) | Track every recruiting lead |
| LinkedIn Recruiter | Identify and message targeted agents |
| Facebook Ads Manager | Run geo-targeted recruiting ads |
| AI tools (ChatGPT, Jasper) | Write ad copy, automate outreach |
| Email/SMS Automation | Keep recruits warm in pipeline |
5. Compensation & Value Propositions That Win
Throwing higher splits at agents is a losing game. Big brokerages will always outbid you.
What agents actually want in 2025:
- Leads that convert.
- Coaching and mentorship.
- Marketing support.
- Work-life balance.
- Technology that makes them faster.
👉 Pro Move: Offer a marketing budget, professional coaching, or admin support instead of just splits. It creates stickiness and real value.
6. Train Your Recruiter (Or Yourself)
Most teams fail because they hand recruiting calls to a random VA or admin. That’s a mistake.
Recruiting is sales. Period.
It’s a career conversation, not just a script.
Your recruiter must:
- Understand splits, commissions, and agent pain points.
- Know how to handle objections (“I already get leads,” “My split is higher”).
- Sell the value, not the paycheck.
What NOT to do:
- Don’t outsource to someone who doesn’t understand real estate.
- Don’t make it a “once-a-week” activity. Recruiting must happen daily.
Retention: The Other Half of Recruiting
Recruiting gets agents in the door. Retention keeps them.
Top retention strategies in 2025:
- Regular coaching sessions.
- Clear career growth tracks (show how an agent can move from 6 → 60 deals).
- Recognition & culture building.
- Cutting-edge tools (AI CRMs, automated marketing support).
Checklist: 10 Retention Levers
- Weekly coaching.
- Transparent comp plans.
- Marketing assistance.
- Admin support.
- Tech stack training.
- Culture events.
- Recognition programs.
- Lead distribution system.
- Career development.
- Open communication.
Recruiting Then vs Now
| 2019–2020 | 2025 |
| Craigslist & Indeed ads | LinkedIn + Instagram + TikTok recruiting funnels |
| Split-based offers | Value-driven offers (coaching, support, leads) |
| Sporadic hiring | Evergreen recruiting machines |
| Manual follow-ups | Automated email/SMS nurture |
FAQs: Real Estate Recruiting 2025
Q: How do you recruit real estate agents in 2025?
A: Use a recruiting funnel, leverage social media daily, run targeted ads, and train a recruiter to close career conversations.
Q: What’s the average agent turnover rate?
A: Around 20–30% annually, higher for new agents. Top producers are always being recruited.
Q: What platform works best for recruiting?
A: LinkedIn for experienced agents, Instagram/TikTok for visibility, Facebook Ads for targeting.
Q: How do you stop agents from leaving?
A: You don’t forever — but you build retention levers (support, growth, culture) and always recruit so you’re never dependent on one agent.
Q: Should I outsource recruiting?
A: No — unless it’s to a trained recruiter who understands real estate. Never dump it on an admin.
Final Thoughts: Keep. Friggin. Recruiting.
The day your top producer leaves doesn’t have to be a crisis. It only becomes one if you’ve neglected recruiting.
The real estate teams that thrive in 2025 won’t be the ones with the flashiest branding or the most leads. They’ll be the ones who treat recruiting as their lifeline — automated, consistent, daily.
Related Articles:
The Hiring Mistake That’ll Cost You BIG: Skipping the Right Questions